The short answer: In New York, "What do you do?" is less a question than a reflex. It is the first thing asked in FiDi elevators, at gallery openings in Chelsea, and across the bar in Williamsburg. Swap it for questions about why and how: what someone is building, what pulled them into their field, what they would do with a free Tuesday. Then ask a follow-up. Harvard research on speed daters found that people who ask more questions, especially follow-up questions, get more second dates.

Why is "What do you do?" a weak first-date question?

New York runs on the ten-second pitch. Bankers in the Financial District, associates at Midtown law firms, producers, founders, attending physicians: everyone in this city has a polished answer ready, because they give it at client dinners, alumni mixers, and conference coffee lines every week. On a date, you get the same recording. It is a LinkedIn summary read aloud, at speed.

It also does double duty as a screening tool, and New Yorkers know it. The answer is quietly converted into data: industry, seniority, likely income, and then the inevitable second question, "So, where do you live?", which sorts the city by neighborhood and commute. Within a minute, two people are not getting to know each other. They are underwriting each other.

The numbers explain why the room is so credentialed. According to U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts (American Community Survey, 2020 to 2024), 41.6% of New Yorkers aged 25 and over hold a bachelor's degree or higher, and in the neighborhoods where professionals actually date, from the Upper West Side to Park Slope, the share runs far higher. In a city this accomplished, a job title tells you almost nothing that distinguishes one person from the next.

The setting is rarely the problem. New York does first dates beautifully: a glass of champagne at Flûte in Midtown, a quiet corner at Jones Wood Foundry on the Upper East Side, cocktails in the West Village or a wine bar in Fort Greene. The rooms are doing their part. The opening question is the weak link.

The problem is not curiosity about work. Work matters to driven people, and pretending otherwise is its own kind of awkward. The problem is that the question asks for a label instead of a story, and New York has labels in unlimited supply.

What does the research say makes a first conversation work?

Two lines of research are worth knowing.

Follow-up questions drive liking. In a 2017 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Karen Huang and colleagues at Harvard studied live get-to-know-you conversations, including an observational study of speed daters. Across their studies, people who asked more questions, particularly follow-up questions, were better liked by their partners. Speed daters who asked more follow-ups were more likely to get a yes for a second date. The researchers' explanation: follow-ups signal responsiveness, the sense that you are listening, understanding and care about the answer. The authors defended the findings against a published critique in 2019.

One detail stands out: people did not expect the number of questions they asked to change how they were seen. Most of us underrate the move that works best.

Gradual depth builds closeness. In 1997, psychologist Arthur Aron and colleagues paired strangers for 45 minutes of increasingly personal questions, now famous as the "36 Questions." Those pairs reported feeling closer than pairs who stuck to small talk. The key was not any single question. It was reciprocal self-disclosure that escalated a little at a time, with both people taking turns.

Put together: ask, listen, follow up, and let the conversation get a little deeper as it goes.

What should professionals ask instead?

These are built for people whose work is a big part of their identity. They let work into the conversation without letting it take over, which in New York also means letting the person out from behind the firm, the fund, or the masthead.

Instead of "What do you do?"

• "What are you working on right now that you're genuinely excited about?"

• "What pulled you into your field in the first place?"

• "What part of your job would surprise people?"

Instead of "Where did you go to school?"

In New York this one carries extra freight, because half the city arrived from somewhere else with a degree doing quiet signaling. Try the version that gets a story instead of a ranking.

• "What's something you studied that you still think about?"

• "Was there a professor or mentor who changed your direction?"

• "If you went back to school tomorrow, what would you study?"

Instead of "Do you travel a lot for work?"

• "What city have you been to that you'd move to in a heartbeat?"

• "What's the best meal you've had on a work trip?"

For when the conversation is going well

• "What does a really good weekend look like for you?"

• "What are you trying to get better at outside of work?"

• "What's a decision you made that changed your life more than you expected?"

How do you ask a good follow-up question?

A follow-up picks up a thread from what the other person just said. It is the difference between an interview and a conversation, and New Yorkers, who interview for a living, can feel the difference instantly.

Take an answer like "I'm in the middle of launching a new practice area." Good follow-ups:

• "What made you decide now was the time?"

• "What's been harder than you expected?"

• "How will you know it's working?"

A switch question ("Cool. Do you like the Hamptons?") drops the thread. A follow-up shows you heard it. Aim for at least one follow-up before you change topics.

How do you make the most of a short first conversation?

At a structured evening, you might have six or seven minutes with each person. That is shorter than a delayed subway ride, and it rewards a plan.

• Skip the résumé. You'll learn their job eventually. Lead with something that gets a story.

• Follow up once, then share. Ask, follow up, then offer something of your own. Reciprocity is what builds closeness.

• Go one level deeper, not five. Save the life-changing questions for a second date. In a short round, "What's harder than you expected?" is plenty.

• Notice the energy. If someone lights up, stay there. That's the thread worth pulling.

• Make a note afterward. Remember one detail from each conversation. On the train home, it makes choosing who to see again much easier.

Frequently asked questions

Is it rude to ask about someone's job on a first date? No. Work is a natural topic for professionals, and in New York it is practically the weather. Just ask about the story behind it, not only the title.

How many questions should I ask on a first date? There's no magic number, but research suggests more questions, especially follow-ups, tend to make you more likable. Balance them by sharing your own answers too.

What is a follow-up question? A question that builds on what your date just said, such as "What made you choose that?" It shows you're listening.

Do the 36 Questions work on a first date? The early ones work well as conversation starters. The later ones are designed for a long, private conversation, so they're better saved for later.

What should I avoid asking on a first date? Questions that feel like a status check: salary, bonus, "What fund are you at?" or "How big is your team?" Save them for later, if ever.

Relish hosts structured singles evenings for business professionals and people who value higher education, in 50+ cities since 2016. Each evening gives you a series of short, face-to-face conversations, the perfect place to put better questions to work. Find an evening near you.

Sources

• Huang, K., Yeomans, M., Brooks, A. W., Minson, J., & Gino, F. (2017). "It Doesn't Hurt to Ask: Question-Asking Increases Liking." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 113(3), 430–452. https://dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/35647952

• Yeomans, M., Brooks, A. W., Huang, K., Minson, J., & Gino, F. (2019). "It Helps to Ask: The Cumulative Benefits of Asking Follow-Up Questions." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 117(6), 1139–1144. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31714109/

• Aron, A., Melinat, E., Aron, E. N., Vallone, R. D., & Bator, R. J. (1997). "The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness." Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 23(4). Summary: https://ggia.berkeley.edu/practice/36_questions_for_increasing_closeness

• U.S. Census Bureau, QuickFacts: New York city, New York (American Community Survey, 2020-2024): bachelor's degree or higher, percent of persons age 25 years+, 41.6%. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewyork/EDU635223

Comment